The use of chemical treatments and post-annealing steps to induce the formation of a surface spinel structure prior to electrochemical cycling can improve the first cycle coulombic efficiency and rate performance. However, further improvements in the first cycle coulombic efficiency and cycle life of these materials are still required. This work investigates several families of surface coatings and compositional dopants in lithium rich layered oxides. Modification of the surface coating and addition of dopants can greatly enhance the first cycle coulombic efficiency while also maintaining or improving cycle stability, voltage fade, and rate performance of the lithium excess material. Wildcat evaluation of the performance of hundreds of surface coatings and dopants shows that certain families tend to improve all metrics. In addition we have demonstrated that certain families, such as metal phosphate and metal fluoride coatings, reduce gas generation during the first cycle as well as subsequent cycles relative to the pristine lithium excess material.